The Chosen

by David Drake and S. M. Stirling



The Chosen is the sixth book in David Drake's "Raj Whitehall" series. Co-written with S. M. Stirling. "The Chosen" has a very Draka-like nation as a villain. Those of you who love to hate the Draka will like this book.

The action takes place on a regressed colony world. After millenia technology has recovered to pre-WWI levels. A emissary from an emerging space-faring empire finds two step-brothers to use as its instrument in restoring civilization. The non-coporeal entity can only provide information and advice. The planet will rise or fall by the brother's efforts.


There's a free sample of The Chosen available online here.

It has more military references than I can get, and I got a *lot* of references.


What follows are MAJOR spoilers for the book.















The all-big-gun ship was an innovation of Jackie(?) Fisher, First Sea Lord of Great Britain before and during WWI. It revolutionized battleship design.

Cowpens is a not-so well known but still important battle from the American revolutionary war. Naming an aircraft carrier Cowpens is a direct reference to the real-world WWII aircraft carrier Bunker Hill.

The aircraft carriers of the Chosen flee the battle. They've run out of airplanes. This refers to an actual problem faced by the U.S in the Pacific theater in WWII.

The main plot point of _The Guns of Navarone_ (TGoN) is worked into the story. It's done so well that the realization isn't jarring. It also shows how such a mission would be accomplished in real life. (This is not criticism of TGoN. BTW, if you liked TGoN try _HMS Ulysses_ by Alistair Maclean.)

The Gut is an actual term used to describe the straits of Gibralter (especially when entering the Mediteranean(?)).

Franco's troops were airlifted by Nazi airplanes into Spain. This started the Spanish Civil War.

After an extended meeting with Franco, Adolf Hitler said he would rather have three teeth extracted than go through that again.

Kneally on a torpedo boat getting run down by a destroyer = John F. Kennedy on PT-109.

The German invasion of Norway in WWII succeeded. The invasion fleet of destroyers was trapped in a fjord by a superior naval British force and utterly destroyed.

Sea forts defending themselves by firing torpedoes is real(?).

The mishmash of competing bureaurcracies staffing different portions of the Chosen aircraft carriers - Imperial Germany did exactly the same thing with tanks in WWI.


The amphibious landing that cut off the Chosen expeditionary from supplies parallels the Allied landing in North Africa.

The destruction of the railroad by resistance fighters exactly parallels similar actions by the Soviets in the destruction of the German Army Group Center in WWII. Right down to using ties and rails from one of the double tracks to repair the other.

Destroying a major force by cutting its lines of communications has several parallels in WWII. Stalingrad and the Destruction of Army Group Center are two examples.

The giant tank built by the Chosen parallels Hitlers obsession with giant tanks. Two prototypes were designed and built(?) by Germany in WWII. Code named Maus it weighed 100 tons.

Porschesmidt is Professor Porsche in Nazi Germany in WWII. "Brilliant stupidity." E.g. Porsche's version of the Panther tank did not have an integral machine gun. When they fought infantry they had "go quail shooting with cannon," in Guderian's memorable phrase.

The dangers of landing almost exactly parallel German bomber losses during night bombing of London in WWII. (The Gotha air heavy bomber might have been real German WWI bomber used for the bombing of London.)

The used of dirigibles by The Chosen reflects German use of the same in WWI and in peacetime. See the Hindenburg disaster. What's less well known is that blimps were used to great effect by the Allies in WWII. They were used to escort supply convoys across the Atlantic. They could spot surfaced submarines at great distances.

The tangle of inefficient bureaucracies is an exact picture of Nazi Germany in WWII. Production efficiency was incredibly low. See _Why the Allies Won the War_.

All the Best,
Joe Bednorz


This website copyright 2006 by Joe Bednorz.